Earnings are typically an amazing time to sell elevated levels of premium in options. The uncertainty that surrounds an earnings announcement will cause the market makers to pump up the options pricing months in advance, and with the more recent broad market volatility, it is juicing up the prices as if they were getting ready to jump on a bodybuilding stage.
If you’ve been around options trading for a while you would know that the typical way to trade earnings is to sell out of the money options and basically create iron condors, short strangles and straddles. The thought behind this is that the expected move, which can be found by taking 85% of the at the money straddle price in the expiration cycle immediately following earnings, will cover the post earnings move in the underlying security about 68% of the time. Yet it’s the other 32% of the time where options prices can explode well beyond the expected move and leave the options sellers as the big losers on the trade.
With these issues in mind, I was on a mission to find a couple different alternatives to trading earnings. Today I present two “nontraditional” ways of trading earnings with options that I have had recent success with.
The first alternative I want to present is actually buying a long strangle. Now I know what you’re thinking, why would I do that, why would I buy strangle that’s a low probability trade? I just had recent success with this in a Morgan Stanley strangle where I bought the 41 put in the 46 call and by the end of the week, the price of Morgan Stanley had jumped up to over $48, so it was quite a profitable trade. I wouldn’t have been able to profit and even would have had losses had I sold the strangle.
Now typically I wouldn’t have put on this trade because of the low probability nature of it, but having seen the option prices, I went ahead anyway. The entire trade was only $22 debit, it was so inexpensive I thought, why not try it and see how goes and that seem to work out pretty well.
The key to success with buying the strangle is recognizing when the price of the earnings trade is too low to sell the options, maybe it’s the right time to buy the trade instead. I would have never sold the trade for only a $22 credit, but to play the earnings lotto and risk just $22, that doesn’t seem like too bad of an occasional idea.
This is not something I would always recommend but it is another tool you can put your toolbox if you see that option prices are low, rather than selling the strangle maybe you could buy one…
After the Announcement Credit Spread
The second strategy that I’ve used in the past that’s worked pretty well is after the earnings are announced, and you see which direction the trade may run, putting a credit spread to follow that trade. I’ve done this before in Netflix where it decided to run up after earnings. Immediately after earnings, like within the first 20 minutes of the market opening, rather than scrambling to take off an iron condor from the previous session, I put on an at the money put credit spread. The next thing I know and hour later, that put credit spread had lost half its value and I was able to take it off very quickly for profit.
The key with this setup is to observe where the trade is headed and sell the option premium while it is still relatively high. The prices won’t be as high as at the close of the preceding session, but it should still be expensive enough to justify taking on the short term risk. Now, there’s every chance the underlying could still turn around, but hopefully by the time that happens, the options pricing will have come down enough where you could bail and keep a little bit of the premium that you sold.
After you see which way that the stock is moving and you feel confident that will continue to go on that way, this is another strategy you could use where you are putting on a credit spread then taking your profits within maybe just an hour or so, following the trend of the market.
I know these two strategies may be controversial to many options traders, but at the same point they’re two different ways to trade earnings that I have been able to profit with. They won’t work every time of course, but if you’re able to watch your trades and make fast decisions, which is how you have to trade earnings, these could be a couple trade setups that you might add to your trading tool kit and be interested in trying.
Christopher M. Uhl, CMA, MOSM
Host of the Wall Street Report, The Fastest News in Finance
Host of the How to Trade Stocks and Options Podcast
Trading Writer for MoneyandMarkets.com
Founder, CEO and Head Trader of 10minutestocktrader.com
*Options are not suitable for all investors as the special risks inherent to options trading my expose investors to potentially rapid and substantial losses. Options trading in a tastyworks account is subject to tastyworks’ review and approval. Please read Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options before investing in options. tastyworks, Inc. (“tastyworks”) has entered into a Market Agreement with 10minutestocktrader.com (“Marketing Agent”) whereby tastyworks pays compensation to Marketing Agent to recommend tastyworks’ brokerage services. The existence of this Marketing Agreement should not be deemed as an endorsement or recommendation of Marketing Agent by tastyworks and/or any of its affiliated companies. Neither tastyworks nor any of its affiliated companies is responsible for the privacy practices of Marketing Agent or this website. tastyworks does not warrant the accuracy or content of the products or services offered by Marketing Agent or this website.
*Free bonuses are from 10minutestocktrader.com, no additional bonuses are offered from Tastyworks. Bonuses include but are not limited to product downloads, free months of platinum services and physical goods. Documented proof of using the 10MINUTE referral code for a tastyworks account opening is required in order to redeem the free bonus offer.